Phoenician Hunter

Phoenician Hunter

Share this post

Phoenician Hunter
Phoenician Hunter
The Merchant Caste

The Merchant Caste

It's just business.

Phoenician Hunter's avatar
Phoenician Hunter
Nov 29, 2023
∙ Paid
40

Share this post

Phoenician Hunter
Phoenician Hunter
The Merchant Caste
4
Share

The Phoenicians traveled the Mediterranean long before the Greeks and Romans, trading, establishing settlements and refining the art of navigation. But who these legendary merchant sailors really were, has long remained a mystery.

There is debate amongst historians whether “Phoenicia” was ever a unified society or consisted of a national identity. Rather, it was a loose alliance of many city-states beginning in modern-day Lebanon and Syria, and expanding throughout the Mediterranean. 

‘In Search of the Phoenicians’ author, Josephine Quinn makes the startling claim that the Phoenicians never actually existed. She argues that the notion of these sailors as a coherent people with a shared identity, history, and culture is a product of modern nationalist ideologies – and a notion very much at odds with the ancient sources.

“They did not in fact exist as a self-conscious collective or “people”. The term “Phoenician” itself is a Greek invention, and there is no good evidence in our surviving ancient sources that these Phoenicians saw themselves, or acted, in collective terms above the level of the city or in many cases simply the family.”1

Josephine Quinn shows how the belief in this historical mirage has blinded us to the compelling identities and communities these people really constructed for themselves, based not on ethnicity or nationhood but on cities, family, colonial ties, commerce, and religious practices.

Other historians have come to the same conclusion; “The categorization of the Phoenicians as a single group with a common ethnic origin is based mostly on geographic and historical conditions, and the way in which they were viewed by others, not the way they viewed themselves.”2

Now where have I heard of a group of dispersed people, linked in similar fashion?

“But merchants have no country, the mere spot they stand on does not constitute so strong an attachment as that from which they draw their gains.” – Thomas Jefferson, 3rd president of the United States. Image: Illustration by unknown artist, public domain.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Phoenician Hunter
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share